Bifalgorithm post · Property · I think clearly

Possession

Possession (Property · I think clearly) — "distinguishable from the present; inasmuch as there the action was for maliciously hindering and disturbing the plai…

Ideas in this flowchart

  • Possession of wild animals must be limited to preserve legal certainty and social order.
  • The earlier case was distinguishable because it involved malicious interference with a private franchise.
  • The reported case stated that the ducks were in the plaintiff’s decoy pond.
  • The ducks were therefore treated as being in the plaintiff’s possession ratione soli.
  • Possession or occupancy of ferae naturae should remain within the limits established by the cited authorities.
  • Merely seeing, starting, or pursuing wild animals does not establish possession.
  • Possession requires wounding, circumventing, or ensnaring the animals so that they lose their natural liberty.
  • The animals must be subjected to the pursuer’s control before an action against an interceptor or killer can arise.
  • Recognizing mere pursuit as sufficient would create quarrels and extensive litigation.
Feed/

Possession

Channel

Property

1 page

"distinguishable from the present; inasmuch as there the action was for maliciously hindering and disturbing the plaintiff in the exercise and enjoyment of a private franchise; and in the report of the same case, 3 Salk. 9. Holt, Ch. J. states, that the ducks were in the plaintiff’s decoy pond, and so in his possession, from which it is obvious the court laid much stress in their opinion upon the plaintiff’s possession of the ducks, ratione soli. We are the more readily inclined to confine possession or occupancy of beasts ferae naturae, within the limits prescribed by the learned authors above cited, for the sake of certainty, and preserving peace and order in society. If the first seeing, starting, or pursuing such animals, without having so wounded, circumvented or ensnared them, so as to deprive them of their natural liberty, and subject them to the control of their pursuer, should afford the basis of actions against others for intercepting and killing them, it would prove a fertile source of quarrels and litigation."

Flowchart preview
Series cover
👍
0
0 comments0 shares

Sign in to view and post comments.