Bifalgorithm post · Vente d'un terrain à sa propre société · A. Were the Transactions Interconnected?

Receipt Argument

Receipt Argument (Vente d'un terrain à sa propre société · A. Were the Transactions Interconnected?) — "The appellants argue that the two receipts—one for the…

Ideas in this flowchart

  • Tax credit entitlement depends on the gift, not on the receipt alone.
  • The appellants argue that the cash receipts and License-related receipts should be treated separately.
  • They submit that the Act contains no statutory mechanism for combining the receipts and determining their combined legitimacy.
  • Mr. Walby and Mr. De Las Alas received separate receipts for the cash and the Licenses.
  • The appellants claim that the separate cash receipts entitle them to a tax credit based on the cash paid.
  • They argue that proving payment of the amount shown on a receipt should be sufficient for the charitable donation tax credit.
  • The Act establishes the legal requirements for claiming the tax credit.
  • A receipt is required to obtain a tax credit under subsection 118.1(2) of the Act.
  • The receipt alone does not establish the gift; it is only evidence of the gift.
  • Under subsection 118.1(3), entitlement to the tax credit is based on an individual's total gifts for the year.
  • Under subsection 118.1(1), total gifts include total charitable gifts and the eligible amount of a gift made to a registered charity.
Feed/

Receipt Argument

No cover

Channel

Vente d'un terrain à sa propre société

1 page

"The appellants argue that the two receipts—one for the cash and the other related to the Licenses—should have been treated separately. They submit that there is no statutory mechanism in the Act for combining receipts and determining their combined legitimacy. Their argument focuses on the receipts and is essentially that because Mr. Walby and Mr. De Las Alas each received receipts for the cash they paid, separate and apart from the receipts based on the Licenses, they should be entitled to a tax credit based on the cash paid. The argument is that the Court should look no further than the receipt and, once the taxpayer establishes that the amount indicated on the receipt was paid, the taxpayer is entitled to claim the charitable donation tax credit. However, while a receipt is a requirement to obtain a tax credit under subsection 118.1(2) of the Act, the receipt alone does not establish the gift. It is simply evidence of the gift. The entitlement to a tax credit is found in subsection 118.1(3) of the Act, which provides that a tax credit is based on an individual’s total gifts for a year. “Total gifts” is defined in subsection 118.1(1) of the Act and includes an individual’s total charitable gifts, including the eligible amount of a gift made to a registered charity."

Flowchart preview
👍
0
0 comments0 shares

Sign in to view and post comments.