Bifalgorithm post · Brisk · Chapter 1

Can two sets with different meanings still be equal?

Can two sets with different meanings still be equal? (Brisk · Chapter 1) — "Note that two sets with different intensions might nevertheless have the same exten…

Ideas in this flowchart

  • Set equality depends on extension, even when intensions differ.
  • Intension and extension are distinct aspects of a set.
  • An intension is the concept or description used to identify a set.
  • An extension is the collection of objects belonging to a set.
  • O is the set of people over 25, while R is the set of people who wear wedding rings.
  • Within the Davies family as the domain of discourse, O and R have the same extension.
  • That common extension consists of Mom and Dad.
  • O and R still have different intensions because they describe different concepts.
  • In another world, older people might not all wear wedding rings, or some younger people might wear them.
  • Two sets are equal if and only if they have the same extension.
  • Therefore, writing O = R is legitimate within the given domain.
  • Likewise, conceptually different quantities can be equal when both have the value 4.
Feed/

Can two sets with different meanings still be equal?

Channel

Brisk

1 page

"Note that two sets with different intensions might nevertheless have the same extension. Suppose O is “the set of all people over 25 years old” and R is “the set of all people who wear wedding rings.” If our Ω is the Davies family, then O and R have the same extension, namely, Mom and Dad. They have different intensions, though: conceptually speaking, they’re describing different things. One could imagine a world in which older people don’t all wear wedding rings, or one in which some younger people do. Within the domain of discourse of the Davies family, however, the extensions happen to coincide. We say two sets are equal if they have the same extension. So it is totally legitimate to write O = R since, by the definition of set equality, they are in fact equal. This is no weirder than saying “the number of years the Civil War lasted = Brett Favre’s jersey number when he played for the Packers.” The things on the left and right side of that equals sign refer conceptually to two very different things, but that doesn’t stop them from both having the value 4, and thus being equal."

Flowchart preview
Series cover
👍
0
0 comments0 shares

Sign in to view and post comments.